Over the past two seasons of The Summer I Turned Pretty, fans have followed Isabel (Belly) Conklin’s coming-of-age story caught between the Fisher brothers, Conrad and Jeremiah.
Now, in the final season, the love triangle that started at Cousins Beach finally comes full circle. The story shifts from teenage summer crushes to real-life choices about love, loss, and growing up. With new conflicts and emotional twists, season three feels like the most mature and dramatic chapter yet.
Season 1 introduced viewers to Belly, a girl who had spent every summer at Cousins Beach with her mom, her brother Steven and the Fisher family.
The first season captured the excitement and awkwardness of growing up. Belly experienced her first real crush turning into something more, the thrill of beach bonfires and the messy way friendships can turn into something different. At the center of it all was Belly’s love triangle with Conrad, a quiet and distant boy she always dreamed of and Jeremiah, the charming and open-hearted one.
Season 2 took a darker turn. Instead of focusing on lighthearted summer love, the season dealt with Susannah’s, Conrad’s and Jeremiah’s mom’s illness and eventual passing. That loss hit everyone hard and completely shifted the tone of the show.
Conrad responded by shutting people out and hiding his emotions. Similarly, Jeremiah tried to hold everything together for those around him, while he was struggling internally. Belly was caught in the middle, facing her own grief while also being pulled deeper into the tension between the brothers. By the end of the season, she chose Jeremiah, but the lingering feelings between her and Conrad made it clear the story was not over.
All of this carried into season 3. With 11 episodes, beginning with a two-episode premiere and then weekly releases, the final season promised to settle the question fans had debated since the very beginning: would Belly end up with Jeremiah, Conrad or neither?
The season opens with Belly and Jeremiah in college trying to make their relationship work — until Belly learns he cheated during a “break.” A family crisis brings everyone back to Cousins Beach, forcing them to confront old feelings. These first two episodes set an emotional tone for the rest of the season. I’d give them an 8/10 for connecting past and present while showing how messy young love can get, even if Belly’s decisions are frustrating.
Episode three centers on Belly and Jeremiah’s engagement announcement, which shocks both families. Their parents disapprove, arguing they’re too young. The family tension feels realistic, but the pacing slows. Still, the emotional conflict is strong. 7.5/10. It’s dramatic, but it makes you question whether they’re really ready for commitment.
Episode four shows Belly pushing for independence while trying to win over her mom. Wedding planning becomes a tug-of-war between love and family approval. Conrad steps in to comfort her, proving that his feelings never disappeared. 7/10, the emotional tension is great, but the story could’ve moved faster.
Episode five flips to Conrad’s perspective, giving viewers a deeper look at his heartbreak. Watching him struggle with loyalty to his brother while still loving Belly is gut-wrenching. 10/10 it’s the most emotionally layered episode and shows how selfless Conrad really is.
In episode six, Belly’s bridal shower becomes an awkward mix of nostalgia and tension. Small moments, like Belly’s slip-up confusing memories of the brothers, say more than words. 8/10. I loved the subtle storytelling here; it proves that her heart isn’t as certain as she pretends.
Episode seven finally lets emotions explode. Conrad confesses his love, Belly hesitates, and the whole love triangle boils over. It’s raw, messy, and impossible to look away. 9/10, it’s the kind of drama fans signed up for from day one.
Episode eight unravels everything: Jeremiah’s secret job, family tension, and a called-off wedding. Belly chooses to focus on herself, heading to Paris for a new start. 7.5/10. It’s chaotic but satisfying, showing that sometimes walking away is growth.
Episode nine slows things down as Belly tries to start over in Paris but ends up adrift. The stolen backpack subplot feels unnecessary, and the emotional spark dims. 5/10. It’s the weakest episode, lacking the emotional weight of earlier ones.
Episode ten rebuilds momentum with healing and forgiveness. Both brothers mature, and Jeremiah finally gives Conrad his blessing. 8/10. It’s quiet but powerful, showing growth that felt overdue.
Finally, episode eleven delivers what fans have been waiting for. Conrad and Belly reunite in Paris, their chemistry undeniable. The ending feels genuine, not forced. 10/10. It’s heartfelt, nostalgic, and a perfect goodbye.
After weeks of anticipation, I’d give the final season of The Summer I Turned Pretty a 7.5/10 overall. As a fan, I have to say Belly was kind of a pain this season, constantly running from her feelings and pushing people away. But maybe that’s what made the finale so rewarding: watching her finally figure out what and who she really wants.
