Why I don’t stand for the Pledge of Allegiance
October 20, 2016
Ever since the beginning of my junior year, I stopped standing for the Pledge of Allegiance. I was hesitant to do this because I was worried about what others would think of me. I knew it would be a risky protest, but I want to make others aware of why I am protesting.
There has been a controversy in the media about 49ers quarterback, Colin Kaepernick, who in the beginning of September kneeled during the national anthem and continues to do so. In an interview with NFL media after the game, Kaepernick explained why he took the actions he did.
“I am not going to stand up to show pride in a flag for a country that oppresses black people and people of color. To me, this is bigger than football, and it would be selfish on my part to look the other way. There are bodies in the street and people getting paid leave and getting away with murder,” said Kaepernick in the interview with NFL media.
I stopped standing for the pledge last year and just recently stopped standing for the national anthem when I heard about Colin Kaepernick doing the same thing. One reason why I stopped standing is because we’re never taught what the Pledge of Allegiance actually means. We start saying the Pledge of Allegiance in kindergarten. We’ve been saying it for so long, I think we’re saying it without knowing why. It’s just something we say every day because it’s a social norm. I think we should be educated about the pledge and then have the choice whether or not we want to say it instead of standing at such a young age without knowing what it means.
Another reason why I stopped standing was because of the line in the pledge “One Nation Under God.” I think this is discriminatory towards people who don’t believe in God or believe in multiple gods.
“One Nation Under God” was added by Dwight D. Eisenhower in 1954 because of national fear of the threat of Soviet Communism. We no longer live in 1954. I think this part of the pledge helps extremist politicians and preachers validate that those that don’t believe in God don’t belong in America.
This contradicts the part of the pledge that says “indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.” Indivisible means we can rise above our differences. We can’t rise above our differences if there are still powerful people in America being discriminatory against people of different faiths.
“Liberty and justice for all” is not provided for minority groups in America. For example, members of the LGBTQ community are refused service in some areas of the country. Also, immigrants who live in Louisiana can’t get married. There are also injustices against African Americans and other races who aren’t white. Some include recent shootings of Freddie Gray, Laquan McDonald, and Samuel Dubose.
Many people have called me out for sitting for the pledge, including teachers. The question I get asked often by other students is “Do you hate your country, is that why you’re not standing?” No, I don’t hate my country. I’m one of the privileged people in this country because I’m white, my family isn’t poor, I get my education, and I rarely face discrimination. So how could I hate living in this country? I just don’t agree with positions our government and our society have taken.
What I hope to achieve when I sit for the pledge is to make other people aware of why I’m sitting. I like when people ask me why I sit so I can educate them about my concerns with this country and hopefully make them look at things from another point of view. I want this country to be more progressive in working towards equality.
I don’t think I can solve the world’s problems just by sitting for the pledge and national anthem. However, I do think sitting makes more people aware of issues in America. I want people to try to be open minded and educate themselves about equality in this country. I think the more people who work for equality, the more likely we can make a difference.
Andrew • Jun 30, 2021 at 12:29 am
I am 36, but when I was in the 7th grade I stopped saying the pledge or would mumble the words and skip the god part.
My reason to not recite the pledge is very simple, it is the antithesis of what America represents. Our democratic republic is built on freedom of dissent from unjust rule and should not require its citizens to pledge allegiance to it. We fought and created a system of government where the people have control with the freedom of speech in public squares.
However I do stand for it with my hands behind me to show respect for others beliefs. I do this as well because my choice to not recite the pledge is my choice alone and by sitting, it could invite the wrong message from others and my intent is just my own personal withdraw, not to rile people up needlessly (the fact that people do get in such a tizzy though is just plain selfish ego)
Kirstin • May 11, 2021 at 9:09 am
I agree fully. Me sitting for the pledge has nothing to do with soldiers who have passed. It has to do with the positions our government and society have taken.
Macey Cunningham • May 3, 2021 at 10:56 am
I completely agree with you. And to the people saying that people in middle and elementary should stand because they don’t understand stand what it means; I’m in 7th grade and understand perfectly. At my school everyone likes Trump and are extremely “basic white people”. Anyways, I would get in trouble if I do this. I completely agree though this is really rude in many ways to people
Ila • Apr 25, 2021 at 2:28 pm
I agree with you. I’m not in school because of covid, but when I get back, I’m gonna sit for the pledge of Allegiance. My friends and Teacher can scowl at me, but they can’t change my mind.
i choose to not say my name • Feb 17, 2021 at 11:16 am
I am a Hispanic and a Bisexual girl living in America. I have been discrimintaed against many times, and people have said racist and homophobic things to me before. I saw a girl in my 7th grade class refusing to stand for the pledge, and the teacher let her. I want to sit during the pledge but I’m too scared. lol yeah
Hailey • Jan 13, 2021 at 2:17 am
Someone in the comments said that they think that kids in elementary and middle school should still do it because they don’t yet understand it but I am in 5th grade and I identify as bisexual and polyamory and I understand completely about what the pledge of allegiance really is and I have been sitting out to this pledge since 4th grade so please rephrase that because, “Age is just a number, however being wise comes from experience” just remember that next time someone says that and I think that’s all thank you for your time reading this, goodbye.
Interested Reader • Nov 1, 2020 at 2:43 pm
I too agree with this, which is why I too am going to not stand for the pledge of allegiance or our national anthem until our country does better. #STOPRACISMANDTHELGBTQHATERS #STOPINEQUALITYOFRACEGENDERANDSEXUALITY
Anonymous • Oct 29, 2020 at 9:54 am
At school i hate standing for the pledge because this is what i believe in and my teacher calls me a Jehovah witness for it . When the times comes for everyone to say the pledge i still half to stand up i don´t have got to say the words or put my hand over my heart but i think i should not stand at all. we should have the option .
Heath Anderson • Oct 7, 2020 at 1:48 pm
The pledge reminds us all about what many Men and some woman have done for your freedom and you just spit on there grave.
Ruben • Oct 6, 2020 at 10:06 am
I completely agree!
Good job!
seth martin • Sep 27, 2020 at 12:57 am
i just recently got called out for sitting during the pledge by this kid in my class and i staright up asked him “why do you stand for the pledge?”……he didn’t know.
Sam • Sep 14, 2020 at 3:52 am
I stand for those that can not. I stand so that you may sit and disrespect our country. American is built on Liberty for everyone. No other country has the freedom of speech protected in their laws. A divided country is a weak country.
Jacob Levinson • Feb 13, 2020 at 10:21 am
One of the main reasons we stand for the Pledge, is to honor the fallen soldiers. The people who died for you to sit where you are sitting. There were many African American soldiers that died and are still dying fighting for your country. The arguement that the LGBTQ community is not serviced in some places is invalid as far as I know, it is illegal to not give service to someone because of Race, Religion, or Beliefs. However my point is this, if you’re not going to say the Pledge, then just stand, stand for those who died and made it to where you can have the freedom you have. If we never fought, be would either be British with strict laws that make it harder to live freely, or we would all be Nazis beating and slaughtering anyone who didnt fit the description of what Hitler wanted. We are the most free version of this country that we can be at this moment. However, fighting against something so important to so many people in this country, isnt going to help. The Civil War wasn’t caused by slavery, however it changed to that a little farther into the war. This kind of thing is no different, there might not go to war with ourselves, but it will divide us again surely. All I ask is for people to stand, if not, atleast stay silent for the moment of silence, that is the worst thing someone could do. I wont try to change how you believe, but atleast dont disrespect others because you think it’s right, people mourne in that moment, and remember the ones they lost, breaking that silence and interrupting them is just plain cruel and unfair to them.
Mercedes Tweed • Nov 30, 2021 at 8:45 pm
I agree thank you for being respectful
Virginia Rhodes • Oct 15, 2019 at 11:07 pm
I 100% agree with this. I am in the eighth grade and have started to protest the pledge. Yes, I may be a straight, white, privileged, female, but I have a 0% tolerance for discrimination against anyone or anything. My closest friend is a transgender female and she gets taunted everyday just because of the right she has to be the gender she feels is right for her. Teachers have made her dress in “boys clothes.” That really just threw me over the edge. And then when it comes to race, you see all over the news how Caucasian male police officers are harassing African-Americans for doing literally nothing at all. I swear in this country and white male could get away with murder yet a black male would get beaten up by the police for going one mile over the speed limit. I guess to sum it all up, I am just so fed up with this country and the people running it. All in all, you shouldn’t get mocked for not standing up during the pledge of allegiance when all you are doing is standing up for what you believe is right.
Jayla • Aug 29, 2019 at 8:20 pm
I do not stand for the pledge because I just don´t support it. I´m an African American Woman and as you can see I do have to face many things, but I will not stand for a flag that wants me to be united and equal with a land that has my ancestors crushed hopes and bleed on it. I have now realized that I shouldn´t stand for the flag cause of it´s history.
Heather • May 15, 2019 at 2:39 pm
“One nation, under God” offends you? Let me ask you this…..do you use American currency in any way? If yes, isn’t that being hypocritical? On every piece of American currency it is printed “In God we trust”. If you believe that the pledge of allegiance is discriminatory for using the word God, then you should be mortified that money says that we all TRUST IN GOD. You won’t stand because of that one word, yet you spend money on a monthly basis. You, my dear girl, are a hypocrite.
If anything in the Pledge of Allegiance offends you, then don’t say it. Standing is a form of respect for what our flag symbolizes today. Just like standing when the bride walks down the isle is a sign of respect for her. Standing as a coffin is brought in to a funeral, again is a sign of respect for the deceased. Standing when a judge enters the courtroom, again, is a sign of respect.
I think people lose sight of reality and just try to find a band wagon to jump on so that they can say “I made a difference”. Why not make a difference in a positive way instead of a controversial way (that you really don’t even understand).
Katie Jones • Apr 24, 2019 at 3:43 pm
grew up in the United Kingdom, and coming over to the US, I didn’t even know what the pledge was. I said it because I didn’t want to be the only one in my fifth-grade class not paying the pledge. Now that I am in seventh grade, I no longer stand for the pledge. I do not want to say that everyone should not stand for the pledge, but people of different ethnicities or backgrounds may feel awkward saying the pledge, which is why they should be allowed to not say it.
Anonymous • Mar 18, 2019 at 9:05 pm
I don’t agree with this. At all. Yeah, the pledge says, “Under God” but you know what else says those words? Every dollar in the USA. Every 1USD, 5USD, 10USD, and so on. They all say, “IN GOD WE TRUST” but nobody complains about that. They’ll take that money any day. And, yes, some people in side the US are racist but you can’t stop that. Eventually, it’ll fizz-out. You cannot put a law against being rascal because that violates the 1st Amendment. This is why we have a class of crimes called hate crimes. Racism has to be allowed but to a certain extent. Groups like the KKK and Nazis aren’t allowed because they kill these kinds of people. As a hispanic, the pledge should be enforced. If you live in this country, you better respect it. And if you don’t like it, then get out. If you can’t get out because of money, get money. There is no reason as to why you cannot escape this country. I stand for the pledge tall and proud, with my hand over my heart and a hat over my shoulder. Some may say that the country is not free and there are limitations. Well, read my comment on racism. And about the whole LGBTQ thing, some religions don’t support that. If I can’t serve you because ur L, G, B, T, or Q, then it is my job to find somebody who will (I would serve you because I really don’t care just don’t preach about it in front of my face). Yes, some people in this country are racist, I’ll give you that. No, you cannot stop racism unless the said person has committed a crime because they are racist. Yes, some people don’t like the LGBTQ community but you can’t stop that because that is their first amendment right. All in all, everyone must stand for the flag because you are in this country so you have to respect it. And, if you don’t like it; then get out.
Anonymous • Mar 12, 2019 at 4:58 pm
Amazing. I’m writing an argumentative essay on this for my district writing assesment.
Mike • Feb 17, 2019 at 6:47 pm
I love it when people can honstly express their thoughts and feelings. The anthem and flag are merely symbols of our country. WE THE PEOPLE are truly what’s important. If we can only get past the symbolism and lift each other up. What a nation we could be. Life and Love to you all!!!!
Kami Jordan • Jan 24, 2019 at 12:49 pm
Omg! This is probably one of the most accurate things i´ve ever read. I am doing a speech in debate class on this topic and this definitely helps a lot! Nobody understands why I don´t stand. But i´m happy to see i´m not the only one!
Lin • Jan 16, 2019 at 8:01 am
Listen. I feel as though the people who are attacking others for not standing or saying the pledge by using the, “You don’t belong in our country, why do you hate this country..etc”. This is exactly why I don’t stand and will never stand for the pledge unless this country gets its act together.
It’s not the country itself, it’s the people that make up the country for what it is and what it stands for. Clearly you people don’t stand for justice and liberty when minorities always get the backend of the stick. It makes me absolutely sick to know how much this country actually hasn’t progressed from its horrible past. I mean if you actually pick up a book and read or reasearch, you’ll see just how terrible America is.
The people who served in the military aren’t the problem, it’s the government who bloats the military and yet when they come home get the back end of the stick. It happens historically across the board, it’s even worse if you’re a minority.
I don’t hate the military, nor do I hate the people serving in the military. I do hate the way this country is going and I am glad however I have the right to speak my mind.
Anonymus • Jan 15, 2019 at 12:51 pm
Isn’t it unfair to african americans that the pledge says “With liberty and Justice for all” When African americans are treated still so poorly? I do agree that “One nation, under God” should be removed. But if the mistreating of african americans keeps up, there might be another civil war!
Anonymous • Jan 15, 2019 at 12:47 pm
i agree. my class is doing a debate on this
Anonymous • Dec 19, 2018 at 10:03 pm
I am glad someone agrees with me. I stopped standing as a sophomore, though I do get quiet to respect those who do stand and do feel that they ought to be respectful.
Awesome411 • Oct 24, 2018 at 2:16 pm
I think that all of you are saying things that are important. While I may not agree with what you all are saying, I do believe that everything anyone says, we should listen. I do agree with Summer because I believe that something needs to be done in this country before it is to late. We need to voice our opnions and make sure that we as a country do something about this issue.
Anonymous • Oct 24, 2018 at 2:10 pm
I think that all of you are saying things that are important. While I may not agree with what you all are saying, I do believe that everything anyone says, we should listen to.
Mina • Aug 24, 2018 at 2:02 am
I think it’s a brilliant idea. My mom will most indefinitely be pissed off but I think it’s worth it. There ISN’T liberty and justice for all, and that’s the problem. Sitting during the PoA isn’t unAmerican. We’re speaking our minds, and it’s our right to do so. And even though I personally believe in God, I don’t think They should be shoved down people’s throats. That will only make people either A) hate God and/or B) hate people who follow Abrahamic religions.
Xavier Virsu • Jun 6, 2018 at 7:41 am
The pledge is to this great republic in which we all live and love. Sure the U.S. has its problems, but name one country that doesn’t. Showing disrespect to this country and the people who died for it is not the way to change these issues. Immigrants to this country show more reverence for that flag than citizens born here. Be very ashamed.
Patricia • May 23, 2018 at 9:50 pm
So recently, i was sitting during the pledge, like usual. And the teacher screamed get up. One out of the three people sitting stood up. The teacher continued to tell us to stand. I just sat there. Tbh I’ve never been so proud ij my life.
Sara Evans • May 16, 2018 at 2:54 pm
I have always felt uncomfortable standing for the pledge and my school tried to force kids several times to stand for it and one even got sent to the office for not doing it.
Anonymous • Apr 26, 2018 at 12:23 pm
I totally agree on this because we should fight for what’s right and the fact that most people don’t even know what the pledge really means and I’m not standing for something that discriminates religions and races
Anonymous • Apr 17, 2018 at 1:34 pm
The problem is the society that are in SOME places in the country. That does not mean that the country, as in its laws, rights, and government, advocates thing such as inequality and injustice. I agree that it is a problem in many parts of the country, but by not honoring those who fought and died for the land we live on, it seems that may advocate more disunity than giving hard earned respect and saying the pledge of allegiance.
Kevin Gravy • Mar 23, 2018 at 10:37 am
To start of with I think that the flag is discriminatory to me because I am actually an muslim so that really grinds my gears. I cant believe that people cant see how there is no physical evidence. I also believe that the earth isn’t flat but I also know its not round. It is actually a beautiful majestic curved donut. its glorious in its every shape and form. I think that the government is corrupted by not telling us the truth about the earth. I do not believe in NASA, and I am disappointed that the government would try lie to us. Of course, this is my opinion, but I know for a fact pubg is better than fortnite. Anyways, I will no longer be standing up for the flag of this country as it makes me feel attacked, because trans people like myself, are treated differently. Thanks for reading, and have a nice day.
John Libby • Mar 23, 2018 at 10:22 am
I personally think that this country doesnt support gays. For example, my mom is gay and she gets treated differently. I dont agree with how this country is treating my mother. Thus, I also prefer that “under god” is removed because I am an atheist and I feel attacked when this part of the pledge is said. I also do NOT think that pubg is better than fortnite. Thus, I would much rather move to canada, as this country is falling apart.
Charis Jobe • Mar 13, 2018 at 11:50 am
I dont stand up for the pledge because were praising soldiers who have killed other soldiers with family’s and kids I dont care if they might be evil or bad but there fighting for what they believe in like we are. And to stand in class praising the united states for that heck n, a teacher can scold me but I will not.
manouny • Mar 12, 2018 at 1:16 pm
i strongly agree with you , however i think that kids who are in elemantary schools and middle schools should still stand for the pledge of allegiance because their still so young to understand what the pledge of allegiance truly means and i think that as they grow up they choose not to stand for it anymore it’s their undoing but i advise they should stand in public because they could disrespect so many families that have their brothers,husbands, sons, ect. who are fighting for their lives everyday.
Aaliyah Wiggs • Jan 17, 2018 at 10:57 pm
I recently got called out by a teacher on sitting during the pledge this helped me on more reasons why I should.
Dalton • Sep 1, 2017 at 5:41 pm
Whether you support this country or, it’s not the country that is racist. It’s the people who have nothing to live for. If you are letting people keep you from saying the pledge, just go to another country. Besides there are guys overseas right now getting killed so that you can speak your mind on the internet. They don’t care if you support them or not. They died for you and you can’t say a simple thing pledge
Anonymous • Sep 30, 2017 at 8:41 pm
Isn’t it patriotic and respectful though to exercise the rights they fought for?
Charis Jobe • Mar 13, 2018 at 11:53 am
Yes it goes both ways
Anonymous • May 2, 2018 at 10:06 pm
exactly. well put
Anonymous • May 14, 2018 at 11:04 am
Oh, snap, he/she just called you out. Not only that, but the flag and the pledge doesn’t just stand for the military or those who fought to defend the country
Anonymous Reply • Mar 27, 2018 at 9:25 am
I agree with you about people overseas fighting for our flag and no one will respect our flag. The Pledge of Allegiance was written in 1892 by Francis Bellamy, the words the flag of the United States wasn’t added until 1923. Also, the words under God wasn’t added until 1954. Have you ever thought about the people that made the Pledge of Allegiance maybe they believe in God, well in the First Amendment is freedom of speech, religion. I think that you are going to live in America then that you should stand for the Pledge of Allegiance but if you don’t believe in God then you still stand for you don’t have to stay the Pledge of Allegiance.
Tracy • Apr 23, 2017 at 3:35 pm
I definitely agree that “under God” should be removed from the pledge, as it has made me personally uncomfortable since elementary school. I’ll be graduating college soon and am hoping to become a teacher. I’ll be back to saying the pledge again. I began sitting through the pledge in high school as well, but as I teacher, I think I should set a different example.
You say that the end “indivisible, with liberty and justice for all” is complicated for you because you don’t think this is an accurate representation of our country. While I agree with that, I think it’s important to pledge yourself to working towards indivisibility, liberty and justice every day.
So I’m not against the pledge, but I will be looking into ways to advocate for the removal of “under God,” and I hope that you find a way to advocate for that as well.
Daizy • Mar 6, 2017 at 5:12 pm
I agree 100% I am glad there’s people out there who agree and have the same view points as me.